The Breakout That Never Came: A Lesson in Volume and Patience
SPY's slide back below its 50-day shows why breakouts need volume and follow-through, not just a new high, to hold up.
A breakout that fizzled before it started
Look at SPY's last ten closes and you can see the story without needing a single indicator. The index put in a run up near 778, stalled, and has been grinding lower since, closing at 759.97 as of October 23, 2026. That's down 0.52% on the day, down 0.43% over five days, and down 0.94% over the past month. Price is now sitting below both its 20-day average (770.15) and its 50-day average (767.81), even though it remains well above the 200-day (727.01).
This is a textbook setup for the lesson at hand. SPY never even attempted a clean breakout here. It rolled over from resistance near 774.03 and is now testing support in the 758.79 to 759.48 zone. But the reason this matters for newer traders isn't the failure itself, it's what would have made a breakout attempt credible versus what makes most of them fail in the first place.
Why most breakouts fail
A breakout is just price moving past a prior high or resistance level. The problem is that price can poke above a level for all sorts of reasons that have nothing to do with real demand: thin trading, a single large order, stop-hunting, or just noise near a round number. None of those produce a move that sticks.
Three things separate breakouts that fail from the ones that don't:
- Volume confirmation. A genuine breakout usually shows volume above the 20-day average, often well above it. On SPY right now, volume is 33.38 million shares versus a 20-day average of 40.59 million, a ratio of 0.82. That's below-average participation, which is a warning sign, not a confirmation, when it shows up on a move in either direction.
- Follow-through, not just a touch. One strong closing print above resistance means little if the next day or two gives it all back. Markets often probe a level, fail, and probe again. The breakouts worth respecting hold above the broken level on a pullback instead of sinking right back under it.
- Alignment with the broader trend. SPY's bigger picture, per the fact sheet, is a pullback within a longer-term uptrend: below the 50-day, above the 200-day, still up 4.53% from that 200-day average. A breakout attempt that fights the medium-term trend (here, a downtrend in the 20 and 50-day) has a much higher failure rate than one that's moving with it.
How to read momentum before you trust a move
RSI and MACD help frame whether a breakout has fuel behind it. SPY's RSI14 is 42.10, below the midline of 50, which reflects the recent weakness rather than strength. The MACD line is -0.349, sitting below its signal line at 1.159, with a histogram of -1.509. That's a momentum profile working against any upside breakout attempt at the moment, not for one.
None of this means a bounce can't happen. It means that if SPY were to push back above a level like 760.40 or the heavier resistance at 774.03, a trader should want to see it paired with volume closer to or above the 40.59 million average, RSI climbing back through 50, and the MACD histogram turning up toward zero. A breakout on light volume with momentum still pointed down is the classic setup that reverses within days.
Rules of thumb worth keeping
Before trusting any breakout, run through a short checklist: is volume above average, has price held the level on a pullback rather than just touched it, and does the move agree with the trend on the daily and weekly chart. If two of the three are missing, treat the breakout as unconfirmed.
For SPY specifically, the near-term setup is a pullback testing support around 758.79 to 759.48, below both the 20 and 50-day averages. A close back above 760.40 would be the first small step toward repairing the chart, with 774.03 as the bigger test. A close below 758.79 would suggest the pullback has more room to run. All figures here reflect the close on October 23, 2026, and none of this is a forecast, just a framework for watching how the next move confirms itself or doesn't.

